A quick and simple guide to choosing the best lubricant for butt plugs. Click now to read more about anal lubes. However, conventional sex-toy-store-owner wisdom has been that you can't use silicone lubricants with silicone toys, such as butt plugs. Buy Butt Plugs | Beginner Anal Plug Trainer Kit | Anal Sex Toys Made of Soft High Plugs are compatible with water based lubricants and should not be used. You might be a seasoned vet with a subscription to the Butt Plug of the Month should be paired with water-based lube (silicone lube degrades silicone toys). Buy Now Amos Anal Plugs by Vamp Silicone, $25–65, MyTulip. Here are the best lubes out there for anal. in anal play with a silicone butt plug, go with a water-based lube and just make sure to use a lot. Anal play for beginners | Using your first butt plug, by Tracey Cox. You simply apply lube then insert into the anus and leave it there while you.